Decades and decades ago, Ted Nelson invented the
concept of hyper-text, which we now use in a Web
browser when clicking on a link to load some other
web page. He tells the story of trying to explain
this concept to an executive back in the '60s. The
fellow knew about computers, but he had never touched
a keyboard because his secretary did all that stuff
on her typewriter for him. Nelson was having a hard
time getting his ideas across about moving quickly
from one piece of information to another when
suddenly the confused executive's face suddenly lit
up with comprehension and he exclaimed, "Oh -- it's a
tape drive!"
It's a funny story now, but the fellow was behaving
reasonably. People always try to relate new
information to what they know already because it's a
technique that usually works.
Not always, though. Boswell seems to be one of those
times when it doesn't.
Boswell archives and organizes your text which sounds
simple. When we try to explain it to folks, they
usually say, "It's a database!"
Others have tackled bits of this problem before using
databases, outliners, hyperlinks, or Artificial
Intelligence. We like to think of them as putting
roller skates on the employees in that 1890s general
store.
Databases are wonderful for keeping track of very
precise information: people who have addresses in a
fixed number of states with permanent names; dollar
amounts that will never exceed a specified limit;
names that will never be longer than a certain number
of characters.
The thing is, there is other information out there
that simply is not neat enough to be dealt with by a
database. You have to deal with e-mails about several
topics and articles about a bunch of different
people; a few lines of poetry you composed on a whim.
Databases were never intended to handle poetry, not
even Haikus. Someone can try to make them do it and,
even if they succeed, you will probably never compose
enough poems in your life to justify getting a
database for them.
Boswell is not a database and it is not trying to be
one. It does different stuff and it works with chunks
of information that people understand quite well but
that are strangers to the precise world of databases.
Boswell is not like other available tools either.
With systems like hypertext, you make all the
decisions -- but you have to make them for
everything, linking every A to every B. This is
accurate, but eats up so much time that you
eventually do not bother any more.
With Artificial Intelligence, all the decisions get
made for you and you have to learn to live with the
results. This saves time, but you often do not get
exactly what you want and you usually are not allowed
to go in and find it for yourself.
Boswell is somewhere in the middle. You make a
decision once ("anything containing Fred's e-mail
address should be categorized under Fred") and
Boswell implements it for everything until you tell
it to stop. Boswell also lets you see out how it
plans to categorize things so you can override all
those decisions if you want to.
Boswell is a completely new way to manage your
information, not a failed attempt to be one of the
others.
|